Two Wisconsin parents who prayed for their daughter to heal rather than seeking medical help faced a judge for sentencing for reckless homicide.
Dale and Leilani Neumann were convicted by separate juries of second-degree reckless homicide last year after their eleven-year-old daughter Kara died of undiagnosed diabetes.
In Marathon County court, a judge decided each parent will serve ten years on probation and up to six months in jail — one month a year for six years during either March or September, the anniversary of Kara’s birth and death, respectively.
Tuesday’s sentencing hearing lasted several hours as both the prosecution and defense presented their case to the judge and Dale and Leilani Neumann defended their actions.
“Nobody understands that but a parent that is grieving for their child,” Mrs. Neumann said.
An emotional Leilani Neumann told a Marathon County judge her family’s life has been turned upside-down every since Kara passed away.
Prosecutors say the Neumanns see themselves as victims for their religious beliefs but it was Kara who paid the ultimate price for their beliefs.
The second-degree reckless homicide charge carries up to 25 years in prison. The State recommended a minimum of a year in jail and ten years’ probation for each parent.
“They appear to love their children but they stood by and did virtually nothing while their youngest daughter died a slow, agonizing death,” Assistant District Attorney Lamont Jacobson argued.
Defense attorneys fought for no jail time at all, claiming their clients are being unfairly prosecuted because of their faith.
Dale Neumann explained to the judge, “Guilty? Of loving my God with my whole being and intellect, that’s what I’m guilty of.”
Despite their religious defense, the judge felt some punishment was necessary for Kara’s sake.
“When death is an element of the defense, you really can’t say death itself is an aggravating factor but when a person who dies is a young child it is,” Judge Vincent Howard said.
According to defense attorneys, the Neumanns won’t serve any of the jail time until the appeal has been heard.
Leaving the sentencing hearing, the Neumanns had smiles on their faces.
“Not right now,” Mrs. Neumann said to the media. “We need a few minutes, you can tell by our faces, but we need to talk to our lawyers first before we make any comments.”
Lawyers on both sides say the judge made a sound decision.
“I think that ultimately the judge determined that incarceration was not the appropriate remedy, and we concur with that,” Mr. Neumann’s attorney, Jay Kronenwetter, said.
“All of us grappled with it. It was clear that it was a difficult case for everyone involved,” Jacobson said.
Dale Neumann’s defense attorney told us the appeal process could take months, maybe even a year.
Judge Gives Probation to Parents in Prayer-death Case
The Central Wisconsin parents convicted in their daughter’s death will not go to prison but will spend ten years on probation and some time in jail.
A judge sentenced Dale and Leilani Neumann Tuesday afternoon for the death of their eleven-year-old daughter Kara. She died of complications from untreated diabetes while her parents prayed over her instead of seeking medical attention as her condition worsened.
Earlier this year, separate juries found each of the parents guilty of second-degree reckless homicide, a charge that carries up to 25 years in prison.
Both parents spoke to the judge at their sentencing hearing, calling Kara’s death an act of God, reading Biblical passages, and saying the only thing they’re guilty of is following their faith.
“Dale and I acted with love toward our daughter to the best way we could have, in the best way we could, because we love her,” Leilani Neumann testified.
“Even if she would have been taken to the hospital, as everyone thinks should have been the case, there’s only hypothetical speculation. There’s no substantiating facts, just hypothetical speculation as to whether she would have even lived,” Dale Neumann said.
Prosecutors argue the Neumanns painted themselves as victims of their religion and showed no remorse that their youngest daughter died.
Assistant District Attorney Lamont Jacobson said, “I feel sorry for the Neumanns because they’re horribly misguided and likely will come away from this experience having learned precious little.”
Judge Vincent Howard asked, “Did God say, ‘Well, Kara, come to me,’ or when Kara arrived did he ask, ‘Why are you here 70 years too soon?’”
The judge called the Neumanns good people who made a reckless decision.
The judge imposed conditions on their probation. There will be a month served in jail each year for the next six years in March or September — the anniversary of Kara’s birth and death, respectively.
They must allow random visits and checks by the public health nurse, and they are required to seek medical assistance in certain circumstances.
The judge said in court this was a very different case than many because of the freedom of religion issue, but he said he examined this case thoroughly before sentencing.
Defense teams for both Dale and Leilani Neumann plan to appeal the convictions
